Levels: Primary, Middle, High, Other
| Name | Level |
|---|---|
| Bloomfield Elementary School | Elementary |
| East Elementary School | Elementary |
| East Jay County Middle School | Middle |
| General Shanks Elem School | Elementary |
| Jay County High School | High |
| Judge Haynes Elementary School | Not reported |
| Redkey Elementary School | Elementary |
| West Jay County Middle School | Middle |
| Westlawn Elementary School | Elementary |
Levels: Primary, Middle, High, Other
Levels: Elementary School, Secondary School, Other - mixed grades
| Name | Level |
|---|---|
| 3088 E 800 N | Elementary |
| Jay County Christian Academy | Mixed Grades |
| Limberlost Creek School | Elementary |
| Loblolly School | Elementary |
| Name | Level |
|---|---|
| Jay Creek School | Elementary |
Levels: Elementary School, Secondary School, Other - mixed grades
